The Southern.Wire
← Back to today's edition
Politics — SA & Africa

Mashaba hands the DA an exit — on one condition: no Zille

The Southern Wire Desk·Johannesburg

Herman Mashaba has found the one lever Johannesburg's coalition math actually responds to, and he is pulling it in two directions at once. In a letter to Democratic Alliance leader Geordin Hill-Lewis, the ActionSA leader proposed that the DA keep running the country's largest city after all — so long as the mayor is not Helen Zille. ActionSA, in his telling, would take the deputy mayorship and let a DA figure other than Zille hold the top job. It is a door left open to the party that topped the polls in Johannesburg. It is also, pointedly, a door built with a single name carved out of it.

That the offer needed making at all says everything about how personal this standoff has become. Zille has long been the DA's most forceful presence in Gauteng politics, and it is precisely that forcefulness Mashaba appears unwilling to govern alongside. His letter does not pretend otherwise: the condition is not about policy, coalition shares or committee seats. It is about who sits in the chair. For a party that spent the campaign insisting it would never again hand power to what Mashaba himself once called an "irresponsible" DA administration, the proposal is a notable softening, provided the DA blinks first on its own candidate.

While that offer sits with Hill-Lewis, a second, more consequential conversation has been happening without the DA in the room. The ANC, ActionSA, the EFF and MK Party have been exploring an alternative arrangement that would instead install Mashaba himself as Johannesburg's mayor, keep Nasiphi Moya running Tshwane, and hand Ekurhuleni to the ANC outright — a three-metro carve-up that would shut the DA out everywhere despite its lead in the vote count. ANC secretary-general Fikile Mbalula has been careful not to commit to either path publicly, saying only that the party's top seven officials will decide once the final results and the ANC's own standing in each metro are formally confirmed.

The numbers explain why ActionSA, not the DA or the ANC, is the one setting terms. Vote counts put the DA comfortably ahead in Johannesburg, with the ANC's own share falling into the high teens and ActionSA landing in the mid-teens — not enough for Mashaba's party to govern alone, but enough to decide who does. That kind of kingmaker arithmetic is exactly why Mashaba can simultaneously dangle cooperation at the DA and negotiate its exclusion with the ANC: whichever side needs his votes more will have to meet his price, and right now neither has been told what that price definitively is.

A clock is running underneath all of it. Councils have a limited window after an inconclusive election to elect a mayor, and that window is already well into its second week since results were finalised, pushing the deadline for Johannesburg to find a leader toward the back end of November. Every day the ANC's top structures take to decide, and every day Hill-Lewis takes to weigh a letter that effectively asks the DA to sideline its own provincial leader, is a day closer to a forced vote nobody can yet predict with confidence.

A city that has seen this movie before

Johannesburg's council chamber is not unfamiliar with exactly this kind of standoff. Since 2016, the city has cycled through multiple mayors as shifting coalition arithmetic repeatedly reshuffled who held the chain of office, each change arriving via a motion of no confidence or a collapsed agreement rather than a fresh mandate from voters. Residents have lived through the consequences in practical terms: capital budgets stalling mid-project when a new administration arrives with different priorities, infrastructure maintenance backlogs growing as political attention shifts to coalition survival rather than service delivery, and credit ratings agencies repeatedly flagging governance instability as a direct risk to the city's finances. Whatever this round of negotiations produces, it will be judged against a recent history in which Johannesburg's governing coalitions have rarely lasted a full term intact.

That history is precisely what makes Mashaba's dual-track strategy so legible to anyone who has watched Johannesburg politics over the past decade. ActionSA itself was born partly out of Mashaba's own turbulent tenure as DA mayor of the city between 2016 and 2019, a term that ended in his resignation after the DA's federal leadership moved in a direction he disagreed with. He knows from direct experience how fragile a Johannesburg coalition can be, and how much leverage a comparatively small party can extract when the two larger blocs need its votes more than it needs either of them. That lived experience is arguably why he is working both angles at once rather than committing early to either the DA or the ANC-led alternative.

What a forced vote actually means

South African municipal law does not allow a council to simply sit indefinitely without a mayor. Once the statutory window after an election lapses without agreement, councils must proceed to a formal vote, conducted in open session, with councillors casting ballots for declared candidates until one secures the support of a majority of those present. If no candidate reaches that threshold in the first round, the process moves to repeated rounds, eliminating the lowest-placed candidate each time, until a winner emerges or the process deadlocks entirely and has to be reconvened. It is a mechanism built for exactly this kind of multi-party, no-outright-winner scenario, but it also means that whichever candidate the ANC's structures ultimately back, and whatever the DA decides about Hill-Lewis's letter, the matter will eventually be settled in a chamber vote whose outcome depends entirely on how disciplined each party's councillors are on the day.

Discipline is not guaranteed. Coalition councils have produced defections and crossed votes before, and a tight multi-round contest is exactly the kind of scenario where a handful of councillors voting against their own party's declared position can swing the outcome. Both the DA and the ANC will be acutely aware, heading into any formal vote, that managing their own benches may matter as much as managing Mashaba.

The national stakes behind a local vote

What happens in Johannesburg will not stay in Johannesburg. The DA and the ANC are simultaneously partners in South Africa's national Government of National Unity, a coalition already under strain following the ANC's worst-ever showing in this month's local government elections nationally. A Johannesburg outcome that locks the DA out of the country's largest city, despite winning the most votes there, would land as a pointed signal about how much the ANC actually values that national partnership when a better local deal is on the table. Conversely, a DA-ActionSA arrangement that keeps Zille's party in the mayoralty, even under a different face, would be read within the GNU as evidence the coalition can still function under pressure. Few of the councillors casting ballots in Johannesburg's eventual vote will be thinking primarily about national politics, but the party leaders managing the negotiation above them certainly are.

What is clear is that the DA's plurality in Johannesburg, Tshwane and Ekurhuleni counts for less in this process than the coalition arithmetic surrounding it. Whether that ends with Zille's party still holding the mayoralty under a different face, or with Mashaba himself in the chair backed by the ANC he once swore never to touch, the result will be decided in rooms the voters who delivered the DA its lead were never invited into.